T-Mobile has reached a formal settlement with New York state authorities following allegations that the telecommunications giant violated the state’s Affordable Broadband Act (ABA). The investigation, spearheaded by the Office of the Attorney General (OAG) and supported by Governor Kathy Hochul, determined that T-Mobile had systematically undermined the intent of the law by imposing restrictive data caps and throttling internet speeds for low-income households that the company was legally mandated to serve.
Under the terms of the settlement, T-Mobile is required to eliminate its 50GB-per-month data cap and cease the practice of throttling download speeds to 600 Kbps for customers enrolled in the state-mandated low-cost broadband program. The company has been granted a 120-day window to bring its operations into full compliance with the New York statute, which includes expanding service availability and ensuring transparency in how these plans are marketed to the public.
A Legislative Battle for Equitable Access
The roots of this conflict trace back to the enactment of the New York Affordable Broadband Act, a landmark piece of legislation intended to bridge the digital divide by ensuring that income-eligible households have access to reliable, high-speed home internet. The law, which mandates that providers with at least 20,000 customers offer affordable service tiers—specifically $15 per month for 25 Mbps speeds or $20 per month for 200 Mbps speeds—was the subject of a protracted four-year legal challenge by industry trade groups.
Major telecommunications players, including industry associations like the CTIA, fought the legislation in court, arguing that the state lacked the jurisdiction to impose such price controls. The industry’s efforts to dismantle the law effectively ended in late 2024 when the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the challenge, clearing the way for New York to begin enforcement in January 2025. T-Mobile’s recent settlement highlights the ongoing friction between state-level consumer protection mandates and the operational policies of major national wireless carriers.
Investigative Findings: Throttling and Exclusion
The investigation by the New York Attorney General’s office revealed a pattern of non-compliance that went beyond simple speed degradation. According to official documents, T-Mobile’s implementation of its low-income plan was structured in a way that significantly diminished the value proposition for the consumer.
The most severe finding involved the imposition of a 50GB monthly data threshold. Once a user exceeded this limit, their connection speed was throttled from a functional 25 Mbps—sufficient for video conferencing, remote learning, and standard web usage—to a mere 600 Kbps. State officials noted that for a typical household, this data cap could be exhausted in as little as four days, rendering the service essentially unusable for the remainder of the billing cycle.

Furthermore, investigators discovered that T-Mobile had restricted the availability of the ABA-compliant plans to areas where it had already deployed 5G infrastructure. This policy systematically excluded residents in 4G-only or LTE-only service areas, despite the fact that T-Mobile provided standard, full-price home internet services capable of meeting the 25 Mbps requirement in those same locations.
Perhaps most critically, the OAG found that T-Mobile had actively obscured the existence of these low-cost plans. The company allegedly implemented "noindex" tags on its dedicated ABA webpage, a technical maneuver that prevents search engines like Google from indexing the content. By making the plans invisible to users searching for affordable internet options, the company effectively limited the number of sign-ups, thereby reducing its liability under the state law.
The Chronology of Non-Compliance
The path to this settlement was paved with mounting public concern and regulatory scrutiny. In June 2025, the New York Department of Public Service (DPS) formally escalated concerns to the Attorney General’s office after receiving reports from consumers regarding the inadequacy of the T-Mobile offering.
This followed an earlier incident involving the cable provider Optimum, which had also failed to provide the mandated low-cost plans. In that instance, investigative reporting prompted the company to reconcile its practices, but the T-Mobile case proved to be a broader, systemic issue. The ensuing 18-month investigation by the OAG culminated in the current agreement, which serves as a stern warning to other ISPs operating within the state.
Corporate Response and Future Commitments
T-Mobile, while agreeing to the settlement terms, did not formally admit to any violation of the law. In a statement provided to the press, the company emphasized its commitment to connecting New York residents while noting that it is currently "updating our plan to meet the state’s requirements while maintaining the same low price."
However, the company’s refusal to acknowledge wrongdoing has drawn criticism from consumer advocacy groups who argue that the settlement is a necessary but insufficient remedy for years of potentially exclusionary practices. The agreement mandates that T-Mobile must:
- Remove the 50GB data cap and the 600 Kbps speed throttling for all ABA-enrolled customers.
- Ensure that the low-cost plans are available at every address where T-Mobile offers standard residential fixed wireless internet, regardless of whether that site uses 5G or 4G technology.
- Remove technical barriers on its website, including noindex tags, to ensure that the plans are discoverable via search engines.
- Prominently feature the low-income plan on its main website pages alongside standard service offerings.
Failure to comply with these terms could trigger a new round of litigation. The state is empowered to seek restitution and civil penalties of up to $1,000 per violation if T-Mobile defaults on its commitments.

Broader Implications for National Telecom Policy
This case occurs against a backdrop of increasing tension between state regulators and the federal government. There is significant uncertainty regarding how the incoming administration might influence state-level broadband laws. The federal government has previously argued that states should not interfere with price regulations, particularly for providers receiving funds from federal initiatives like the $42 billion Broadband Equity, Access, and Deployment (BEAD) program.
California and New York are currently leading the pushback against federal preemption, asserting their right to regulate consumer protections within their borders. Should the federal government attempt to invalidate the New York Affordable Broadband Act, it would likely spark a massive legal battle regarding the balance of power between state utility commissions and federal communications oversight.
A Pattern of Regulatory Friction
The T-Mobile home internet settlement is not an isolated incident. Only last month, the New York Attorney General’s office secured a separate deal with the carrier regarding the company’s "Price Guarantee" marketing. That investigation found that T-Mobile had misled customers by promising "lifetime" price protection on certain plans, only to later increase rates by $5 per line in 2024. That settlement provided approximately $38 million in potential value to consumers, further cementing the image of T-Mobile as a company under heavy scrutiny for its customer-facing business practices.
As the telecommunications industry continues to shift toward fixed wireless solutions—utilizing cellular networks to provide home internet—the regulatory framework governing these services remains in flux. The New York case serves as a critical precedent: it establishes that service quality, transparency, and accessibility are not negotiable, even when companies attempt to leverage the limitations of wireless technology to justify subpar service for vulnerable populations.
Looking forward, the success of this settlement will depend on rigorous monitoring. New York authorities have signaled that they will be watching closely to ensure that the "120-day transition" is not merely a delay tactic, but a genuine overhaul of T-Mobile’s local broadband policy. For millions of New Yorkers, the outcome of this enforcement effort is more than just a bureaucratic win; it is a vital step toward ensuring that the digital age remains accessible to all, regardless of income level or geographic location.


